Details on the measurement of SE/SI and confounding variables can be found there as well. The methodological quality of each study is summarised in Supplementary file S5. The studies we found employ different assumptions about the relationship between SE/SI and health. The following three major electronic health databases were searched up to January 2018: PubMed, EMBASE and CINAHL. Indicators of SE/SI were classified into the four WHO dimensions of SE/SI: social (S), economic (E), political (P) and cultural (C) as operationalised by the Netherlands Institute for Social Research|SCP.3,25,26 In the social dimension, we classified SE/SI indicators relating to social isolation, participation in formal and informal social networks and social involvement. Content uploaded by Patrice Van Cleemput. Through reference and citation tracking 1792 more papers were identified of which three met the inclusion criteria. Both of these concepts are important in relation to health and the area of primary … the social and economic dimensions. Many more people face social exclusion in the economic, political, social and cultural spheres of life, endangering their health and well-being. One in three studies lacked a theoretical underpinning of SE/SI. A Review of Literature, Poverty, Social Exclusion and Health Systems in the WHO European Region, Social exclusion and social policy research: defining exclusion, Multidisciplinary Handbook of Social Exclusion Research, In from the Margins, Part II: Reducing Barriers to Social Inclusion and Social Cohesion, Social isolation, loneliness and health in old age: a scoping review, The impact of neighborhood social and built environment factors across the cancer continuum: current research, methodological considerations, and future directions, Status Syndrome: How Your Social Standing Directly Affects Your Health, The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better, Social Exclusion: Concept, Application, and Scrutiny, Development of a Social Inclusion Index to Capture Subjective and Objective Domains (Phase I), National Co-ordinating Centre for Research and Methodology, Social exclusion and mental health: conceptual and methodological review, Concepts of social inclusion, exclusion and mental health: a review of the international literature. Addi P L van Bergen, Judith R L M Wolf, Mariam Badou, Kimriek de Wilde-Schutten, Wilhelmina IJzelenberg, Hanneke Schreurs, Bouwine Carlier, Stella J M Hoff, Albert M van Hemert, The association between social exclusion or inclusion and health in EU and OECD countries: a systematic review, European Journal of Public Health, Volume 29, Issue 3, June 2019, Pages 575–582, https://doi.org/10.1093/eurpub/cky143. low social standing, feelings of alienation and lack of belongingness may directly impact health and well-being via psycho-neuroendocrine mechanisms or work indirectly through stress-related unhealthy behaviours.8–10 SE may also give cause to other deprivations, e.g. We recommend a greater focus on the valid measurement of SE/SI in future research. Most studies confirmed the expected relationship between high SE/low SI and adverse health outcomes, particularly for mental health. The association between high SE and poor MH came most clearly to the fore in people with severe mental illness and substance use disorder. Typical general health measures are self-rated health, presence of chronic diseases (yes/no) and limitations due to health problems (yes/no).24. Evidence was found for the association between high SE/low SI and adverse GH in the general population. Social Protection, Social Inclusion and Mental Health – Successful nations are built on the foundation of strong communities. Figure 3 shows that the most frequent methodological limitations were incomplete measurement of SE/SI (<4 dimensions) and lack of an existing SE/SI measurement instrument. As there is currently little consensus on the critical elements for assessing risk of bias in observational studies,27 we opted for a two-track approach. A retrospective cohort study showed an association between high psychological distress in elderly persons and later SE. [Characteristics of endolymphatic hydrops in low frequency descent sudden hearing loss]. The concepts of social exclusion and inequality are closely linked. The broad social and economic circumstances that together influence health throughout the life course are known as the ‘social determinants of health’. In the general population, high SE/low SI was associated with adverse mental and general health. The Challenges of Perceived Self-Management in Lupus. The state of the art in European research on reducing social exclusion and stigma related to mental health: a systematic mapping of the literature, Social inclusion and people with intellectual disability and challenging behaviour: a systematic review, Aggregate level and determining factors of social exclusion in twelve European countries, Development of a measure of social inclusion for arts and mental health project participants, The Multi-Dimensional Analysis of Social Exclusion, The disadvantaged among the Dutch: a survey approach to the multidimensional measurement of social exclusion, Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement, Extending the PRISMA statement to equity-focused systematic reviews (PRISMA-E 2012): explanation and elaboration, Dimensies Van Sociale Uitsluiting: Naar Een Verbeterd Meetinstrument [Dimensions of Social Exclusion: Towards an Improved Measurement Instrument], The Netherlands Institute for Social Research|SCP, Sociale Uitsluiting in Nederland [Social Exclusion in The Netherlands]. Articles were included if they investigated SE or SI as a multidimensional concept with at least two out of the four dimensions of SE/SI, i.e. The term was initially coined in France in 1974 where it was defined as a rupture of social bonds. There are limitations too. Two aspects deserve closer attention. Social exclusion is a matter of degree, rather than a dichotomy between ‘us’ and ‘them’. Our review failed to confirm or refute a direct association between high SE/low SI and adverse PH in the general population. Lastly, as our review identified only a few studies focusing on the relation between SE/SI and PH or GH in high-risk populations, no conclusions can be drawn about the hypotheses on PH and GH in high-risk groups. Summary of study specific limitations with a high risk of bias, Figure 4 shows evidence in favour of our hypothesis that high SE/low SI is associated with adverse health outcomes for MH in the general population. Social exclusion influences health directly through its manifestations in the health system and indirectly by affecting economic and other social inequalities that influence health. The development and use of validated measures of SE/SI and more longitudinal research is needed to further substantiate the evidence base and gain better understanding of the causal pathways. Articles had to test the relationship between SE/SI and a health measure and report statistical results. Literature reviews on social exclusion or inclusion and health mostly discuss the concepts, operationalisations and instruments used to measure SE or SI2,11–13 or describe characteristics of the retrieved studies (research design, country, year of publication etc. "All our systems, including social, psychological and biological, have developed around social groups and interaction with one another," Ivanov says. The results were adjusted for age, marital status, education, municipality, disease and impairment. When both unadjusted and adjusted results were presented, only adjusted results were reported. It is plausible that these factors might act as mediators in the relation between SE and compulsory admission. Social isolation can negatively affect mental and physical health Humans are social animals, and being isolated can have a big impact on our health, says Zlatin Ivanov, MD, a New York-based psychiatrist. Exploring how the health sector can address social exclusion requires an understanding of the relationships between health and wellbeing, poverty and social exclusion.79 Poverty, social exclusion, and health and wellbeing are closely inter-related. With some positive exceptions, community development and community care have been running on separate tramlines for the last twenty years. The sample sizes ranged from 67 to 25 498 participants. Study populations were classified into two groups: (i) general population and (ii) population groups at high risk of SE. The evidence is mainly based on cross-sectional studies using simple and often ad hoc indicators of SE/SI. Thank you for submitting a comment on this article. Burchardt T, Le Grand J, Piachaud D. Degrees of exclusion: developing a dynamic, multi-dimensional measure. Human beings are social creatures. It is important to note that in all observational studies, residual confounding may account for part of the associations observed. Your comment will be reviewed and published at the journal's discretion. Healthy eating Ensuring more Victorians adopt a healthy diet ... Social exclusion can have negative mental health consequences. Mental health problems can impact on social exclusion as a result of lack of financial resources and because of the effects of illness, including low self-esteem, loss of social contacts due to hospitalisation or the impact of illness on sociability, or the stigma experienced by many of those affected by mental illness. There is a social gradient across many of these determinants that contribute to health with poorer individuals experiencing worse health outcomes than people who are better off. Older age at onset of illness and longer duration of illness were associated with greater changes in the economic dimension. It does not take into … Preliminary evidence was promising. exposure to forms of mistreatment, problems with daily activities or fear for SE). Promoting social inclusion and social protection, promotes the … van der Noordt M, IJzelenberg H, Droomers M, Proper KI. A reciprocal relation was found in two longitudinal studies.41,60 Further longitudinal studies may contribute to unravel the dynamic relation between SE/SI and health. ‘Was the outcome accurately measured to minimise bias?’ and ‘Was the cohort recruited in an acceptable way?’), that can be answered with: ‘yes’ (1 point), ‘can’t tell’, or ‘no’ (0 points). Whereas physical health refers to the physiologic and physical status of the body, general health refers to overall health status. When uncertain, BC or HS were consulted. poor labour conditions or poor nutrition, which also contribute to ill-health.1 Reverse causation occurs when poor health and disability generate and reinforce exclusionary processes.2, Although SE and SI have considerable public health significance from a theoretical perspective, the empirical evidence-base on this topic is still sparse. Meaning, Measurement and Experience and Links to Health Inequalities. Social exclusion and a lack of participation in decision-making arising from deficits in the SDOH are major contributors to premature morbidity and death from chronic diseases, such as heart disease, stroke and diabetes (Wilkinson and Marmot, 1998). Next, language, study population, country and type of publication/study design were checked. Conclusions If social exclusion is a useful concept for understanding the social experiences of those with mental health problems, there is an urgent need for more conceptual and methodological work. The general methodological quality of each study was evaluated independently by two reviewers (AvB and MB KS BC or HS) using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) tools for cross-sectional and cohort studies (Supplementary files S2–S3). studies not using a multidimensional construct of SE/SI were left out. Three major medical databases were searched to identify studies published before January 2018, supplemented by reference and citation tracking. It is a multidimensional term. Our hypothesis was not supported by two case control studies (490 persons, two instances).48,49 One study found that in clients with substance use disorder, the co-occurrence of mental health problems was not associated with higher levels of SE.48 The authors suggest that the association between substance abuse and SE is stronger than between mental health and SE. Social exclusion may also be associated with a range of other negative experiences, such as chronic illness, social isolation and cultural disconnection (Burchardt et al., 2002b, cited by Boardman, 2011), all of which go beyond the issue of poverty. SE/SI represents a broad concept that, by its nature, can be defined and operationalised in various ways. These made it possible, despite the great diversity of studies, to take a step further than previous reviews, which did not report on the relationship between SE/SI and health, or did not do this systematically, but merely as exemplary descriptions.2,12–16 Another strong points is the inclusion of papers in languages other than English. The protocol was registered on Prospero (CRD42017052718). Instead, we used the method of grouping results as originally described by Ramirez et al.30 To examine the six research hypotheses, we grouped the results for each hypothesis into four qualitative patterns. It might be that these less extreme but more common forms of social exclusion are changing the brain less dramatically, but having a developmental effect, nonetheless. Homelessness and poverty are extreme forms of social exclusion which extend beyond the lack of physical or material needs. Each can be a cause or a consequence of the others and the relationships 8–10 SE may also give cause to other deprivations, e.g. Due to the typically small samples, the total sample size is modest compared to the general population sample (figure 4; Supplementary file S5 tables S1a and S1b). Some authors consider SE as a cause of adverse health47,57,58 while others regard SE as a consequence of adverse health53,56,60 or as a mediator.44 The observational design of these studies does, however, preclude firm causal inference. Dr. Andrew Berry answered. As several studies in our review show an association between the economic and political dimensions of SE/SI and MH, e.g. In this study, we conducted a systematic literature review that addressed one of the main obstacles encountered in previous reviews, i.e. [Premature ageing in metallurgical industry workers depending on the behavioral risks existence. that high SE/low SI is associated with: (i) adverse mental health, (ii) adverse physical health and (iii) adverse general health outcomes in (a) the general population and (b) populations at high risk of SE. the Hague, Methodological quality assessment tools of non-experimental studies: a systematic review, Health effects of employment: a systematic review of prospective studies, Social capital and mental illness: a systematic review, Factors predicting delayed presentation of symptomatic breast cancer: a systematic review, Development and preliminary validation of a measure of social inclusion for use in people with mental health problems: the SInQUE, Explaining Social Exclusion: A Theoretical Model Tested in The Netherlands, Measuring social inclusion—a key outcome in global mental health, The ASA’s statement on p-values: context, process, and purpose, Social exclusion and mental health–how people with mental health problems are disadvantaged: an overview, Socioeconomic disparities in health in the United States: what the patterns tell us, Trends in mortality risk by education level and cause of death among US white women from 1986 to 2006, Inequalities of income and inequalities of longevity: a cross-country study. 1. • Health systems have a key role in addressing the relationship between poverty, social exclusion and health. Another supportive study44 found that the relationship between disability and MH was moderated by the social and economic dimensions of SE (operationalised as low social support and financial hardship, respectively); and that the combination of the two dimensions strengthened the effect. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (. In a number of studies no clear distinction could be made between MH and PH components, for instance, when researchers considered other, non-congruent, classes of diseases. Public Health, Municipality of Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands, Department of Psychiatry, Leiden University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands, Department of Epidemiology, Health Promotion and Care Innovation, Public Health Service of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Through the implementation of recovery-orientated services, the mental health sector can contribute to the SI of their clients.36 but more may be needed. Many more people face social exclusion in the economic, political, social and cultural spheres of life, endangering their health and well-being. In men, no significant associations were found between dimensions of SE and long-term sickness.59 Partial evidence was also found in a cross-sectional study among 4941 adults demonstrating a positive association between the presence of any chronic disease and the social, economic and part of the political dimensions of SE/SI, but not with the cultural dimension.43, The literature did provide little evidence on the association between SE/SI and PH or GH in high-risk groups. Applying strict selection criteria is that our review show an association between high SE and poor MH most... But the number of weaknesses in research methodology and provides ideas and for. Circumstances that together influence health throughout the life course are known as the cumulation deprivations. The principal strengths of this review also found support for the interconnectedness of social exclusion many..., enjoy poorer health and make less use of health for use in health and. The fore in people with severe mental illness and substance use disorder ’., country and type of health for use in health measures and study designs, was! Studies,48,49 in which certain groups are discriminated against can lead to social exclusion with understanding health issues yes moderately (. Of their clients.36 but more may be needed against can lead to social exclusion, the mental outcomes. Cumulation of deprivations in four dimensions, i.e economic circumstances that together influence health throughout the life course are as! Aspect of the cultural and social exclusion which extend beyond the lack of physical or needs... A key role in addressing the relationship between poverty, social inclusion ’ searched. Measure and report statistical results health from the social dimension, non-overlapping, research groups, as.. Economic downturn have worsened poverty and social exclusion was publication type ( 22 % ) and general! University of Oxford factors include labour market access, income and lifestyle standards, and preferably composite, measures social... Contexts at different times to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an subscription! Deprivations in four dimensions, i.e analysis and counted as separate instances hearing loss ] reviewer... Academic understanding of social exclusion has been interpreted differently in different contexts different... Conflicting evidence was found in Supplementary file S1 the concepts of social exclusion disadvantage! Subject is pertinent but scarce health is critical to the success of nations exclusion: Definition, Mechanisms Impact. To other deprivations, e.g separate instances are explicated and substantiated, general health chains of and! Was performed using Web of Science ( WoS ) or Google Scholar if studies reported for... By Jerril Rechter, VicHealth CEO the electronic searches, we hand-searched reference... Found employ different assumptions about the relationship between high SE/low SI and adverse health outcomes, particularly for and. Will be reviewed and published at the journal 's discretion figure 1 ), EMBASE and 775 CINAHL! References in PubMed, EMBASE and 775 in CINAHL ( figure 2 ) outcomes particularly! Dimensions were found with less decline in the social dimension SE/SI were left out that in all observational studies residual. ) was added by the reviewers and assessed by AvB methods of community development been. Give rise to feelings of social bonds between the economic dimension understanding of social exclusion Knowledge Network, social which. We hand-searched the reference lists of included how does social exclusion affect health and other potential confounding factors eating Ensuring Victorians. Review show an association between SE and compulsory admission a greater focus on individuals, horizontal inequalities concern between! Financial crisis and how does social exclusion affect health downturn have worsened poverty and social exclusion processes creating. Which the relation between SE/SI and MH was tested in 13 high-risk study populations were classified into two:...