Anxiety

Coffee Conversation: Why the Alarm Rings and How We Retrain It

Coffee Conversation: Why the Alarm Rings and How We Retrain It

By Dr. Douglas Cowan, Psy.D., MFT

This is an imagined conversation around a table in a quiet coffee shop. The people are fictional. The research they talk about is real, and you can find it in the articles linked at the bottom. Pull up a chair.

The people at the table:

Doug: Dana, I’ll start with you. What brought you here?

Dana: Eli. Last Tuesday he stood at the front door, white as a sheet, and said his chest felt like it was going to explode. The doctor found nothing wrong. He says, “I know it’s stupid, Mom. I just can’t stop it.” And honestly, I do the same thing before a presentation.

Doug: Nothing stupid about it. Ingrid, what’s going on in his head?

Dr. Solheim: Think of a smoke detector. Deep in the brain is a structure called the amygdala that functions much the same way, scanning for danger and sounding the alarm before we have time to think. A large analysis of imaging studies in 2007 pooled results from people with social anxiety, phobias, and PTSD, and all three groups showed more activity than comparison groups in the amygdala and in a neighboring region called the insula, both of which are linked to negative emotional responses.

Dana: So his brain really is doing something different.

Dr. Solheim: Something more intense, yes, though I would add a caution. Those findings are group averages, so we cannot scan an individual teenager and declare what is wrong with him. What the research provides is a useful picture of how the alarm system operates.

Doug: And the alarm has a partner, right?

Dr. Solheim: It does. The front of the brain, the prefrontal cortex, helps judge how serious a situation really is. One review describes a circuit between the two regions in which the alarm reacts quickly and the prefrontal cortex can turn the reaction down when circumstances allow. The authors conclude that the strength of that communication is closely tied to how much anxiety people report.

Dr. Torres: Which is the hopeful part. A conversation can be strengthened.

Dana: How? Because “calm down” doesn’t work. I’ve tried. So has he.

Dr. Torres: It will not, and I would retire the phrase. When the alarm is blaring, the reasoning part of the brain is difficult to reach, so I ask families to separate two moments: the surge and the practice. The surge is not the time to teach. The practice happens on a calm Saturday morning.

Doug: Say more about practice.

Dr. Torres: Start with the body. A randomized study in 2023 asked adults to practice one of several five-minute breathing exercises daily for a month. The exercise that emphasized long, slow exhalations, often called cyclic sighing, improved mood and slowed breathing more than mindfulness meditation did. Five minutes is something Eli can do sitting on the edge of his bed, and there is a free guided breathing exercise on our site that paces the breaths for him.

Dr. Solheim: I would add that it was a remote study and that breathing is one tool, not a cure. Still, it costs nothing and takes very little time to try.

Dana: And the other direction? The thinking side?

Dr. Torres: Teach him to name it: “My alarm is going off, and my body believes there is a threat.” In one laboratory study, people who paused to evaluate a frightening picture showed less amygdala activity and more prefrontal activity than when they simply reacted to it. Naming is a small act of evaluation, and it also removes the shame, which acts as a second alarm layered on top of the first.

Doug: Rachel, you bring a positive psychology lens to all this. What do you see in Eli that his symptoms hide?

Dr. Torres: A perceptive teenager who notices everything around him. Martin Seligman’s work reminds us to ask what is right with a person as well as what is wrong, and Eli’s brain registers details that others overlook. That quality is a genuine asset in a nurse, a mechanic, a musician, or a pilot. Our task is to help him lower the volume without switching off the sensitivity.

Dana: I never thought of it that way. I’ve been watching him for what is broken.

Dr. Torres: Many parents do, and it comes from love.

Doug: Let me bring in the part that tempts all of us, which is avoidance. Dana, what happens when Eli stays home?

Dana: He feels better. Right away.

Dr. Solheim: That relief matters. A review of anxiety and decision-making notes that fear and worry can bias choices toward avoiding anything that might end badly, so the alarm learns that staying home was the correct response and tends to ring louder the next time.

Doug: So the question becomes how to help him take small steps toward school instead of away from it.

Dr. Torres: Yes, in very small increments. He walks to the car, then sits in the parking lot for two minutes, then attends first period only. We celebrate the effort and not merely the outcome, and we catch him doing it right.

Dana: What about movement? His doctor mentioned exercise.

Dr. Solheim: A meta-analysis pooled six trials involving 262 adults and found that exercise reduced anxiety symptoms more than the control conditions did. That is a small body of evidence, so I would call it promising, but exercise benefits the body regardless, and he can choose an activity he enjoys.

Doug: And breakfast. I encourage families to start the day with protein, like eggs and bacon, instead of sugary cereal. Caffeine can also imitate anxiety, so a teenager with an energy drink and no breakfast is handing the alarm extra fuel.

Dana: Okay. That one I can do tomorrow.

Doug: One more thing. If symptoms keep getting in the way of school or friendships, talk with a licensed therapist. Cognitive behavioral therapy has strong research behind it for anxiety. Some families also ask about non-medication options like neurofeedback. Those are worth a conversation with a qualified provider. And medication decisions belong with your doctor.

Dana: I came in thinking I had to fix him.

Doug: You don’t have to fix him. You have to walk beside him while his brain learns something new. Brains can learn. That is the whole point.

Dr. Torres: And you get to learn it alongside him.

Dana: Before my next presentation, I’m going to try the slow exhale.

Doug: Try it tonight at the kitchen table, too. Make it a family habit. Freedom is the goal. It starts with five calm minutes and a few small steps.

Keep Reading

This conversation is fictional and for education. It is not a substitute for care from a licensed professional. If you or someone you love is in crisis, call or text 988.


About the author. Dr. Douglas Cowan, Psy.D., is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist with 40 years of clinical experience and over 35 years in neurofeedback, licensed and practicing since 1988. Read his full credentials →