Coffee Conversation: Learning to Live Without All the Answers
By Dr. Douglas Cowan, Psy.D., MFT
This is an imagined conversation at a corner table in a coffee shop. The people are fictional. The research they discuss is real, and you will find the full references in the linked articles below.
The people at the table:
- Tom, 46, a project manager and father of three. He lies awake most nights running “what if” scenarios about work, money, and his kids.
- Dr. Henrik Lund, a university researcher who studies how people respond to uncertainty.
- Dr. Rachel Torres, a private practice psychologist who draws on positive psychology and the writings of Martin Seligman.
- Doug (Dr. Douglas Cowan), who is moderating.
Doug: Tom, thanks for coming. What is a typical night like?
Tom: I’m tired, I get into bed, and my brain opens a new browser tab. Did I answer that client correctly? What if the layoffs come? What if my son’s cough is something serious? An hour later I’ve solved nothing, and I’m exhausted.
Doug: Henrik, does that sound familiar from the research side?
Dr. Lund: Very. The term we use is intolerance of uncertainty, which means a strong discomfort with not knowing. Studies have linked it to worry and also to social anxiety, panic, obsessive-compulsive symptoms, and depression. In one sample of 328 people seeking treatment, it was associated with every one of those.
Tom: So it’s not just me being a worrier.
Dr. Lund: It is a pattern many people share. Another review describes it as a fear of the unknown that cuts across diagnoses, and it helps explain why your mind keeps searching for a final answer.
Dr. Torres: And let’s be fair to Tom’s brain. It’s trying to protect him. A lot of people tell me, “If I stop worrying, something bad will happen.” Worry feels like a seatbelt.
Dr. Lund: There is a theory that fits that feeling. It proposes that people who worry heavily may be especially sensitive to sudden drops from feeling fine to feeling awful, so worry keeps them slightly on edge to soften the impact of a bad surprise. It is one model among several, and researchers still debate it, but clients describe that experience to me regularly.
Tom: That’s me. When things are calm, I get nervous that I’m missing something.
Doug: Rachel, how do you see Tom through the positive psychology lens?
Dr. Torres: A man who cares deeply about his family and his work, who anticipates problems, and who takes responsibility seriously. Martin Seligman encourages us to examine strengths first, and Tom’s mind is exceptionally thorough. The difficulty is that the thoroughness has no off switch, so our goal is to keep the quality and return him to the position of being in charge of it.
Tom: I like that better than “you’re broken.”
Dr. Torres: You’re not broken. You’ve been running an overtime shift.
Doug: Let’s get practical. Tom, what is the first thing you try?
Dr. Lund: I would begin by sorting the worries. Some have a next step, such as paying the invoice or calling the doctor about your son’s cough, and you simply take it. Others are pure “what if” questions with no available action, and for those the work is learning to sit with the open question.
Tom: And how do I do that without spiraling?
Dr. Lund: With small experiments. A research group ran a randomized trial with 60 adults who had generalized anxiety disorder. Over twelve weekly sessions, the participants used behavioral experiments to test their fears about uncertainty, and compared with a wait-list group they improved on worry, anxiety, and the other outcomes measured, with gains maintained through a one-year follow-up. It was one modest study, and most participants were women, so I would not oversell it, but it points toward a useful method.
Doug: What does an experiment look like for Tom?
Dr. Torres: Something low-stakes, like ordering a dish he has never tried, sending a text without rereading it, or skipping the third check of an email. Beforehand, he writes down what he predicts will happen and how well he expects to cope, and afterward he compares the prediction with the result.
Tom: And if it goes badly?
Dr. Torres: Then we learn something, and we help you through it. Sometimes people discover they coped better than they predicted, but we find that out by testing it and not by promising it.
Doug: I teach one more tool. A worry window. Fifteen minutes in the early evening. When a worry shows up at 2 a.m., you jot it down and tell it, “You have an appointment at 6:30.”
Tom: My wife would love that. She says I bring the office to bed.
Doug: Write tomorrow’s three tasks on a card, put the phone across the room, and let the card hold what your mind has been trying to hold. Add some exercise during the day and slow breathing at night, with long exhales. Our free guided breathing exercise will pace it for you. Those help the body’s alarm settle so the thinking brain can do its job.
Dr. Lund: And if the worry continues to interfere with work or sleep, see a licensed therapist trained in cognitive behavioral therapy. In one study, patients receiving up to 18 weeks of this kind of treatment showed declines in intolerance of uncertainty, and larger declines went along with larger improvements in symptoms. Questions about medication belong with your doctor.
Tom: I always thought I had to get certain first and relax second.
Doug: Many of us do. It works the other way around. You build the ability to carry the open question, and the relaxation follows. There is an old line that fits: take no thought for the morrow, because tomorrow will take thought for itself.
Dr. Torres: And you can start tonight.
Tom: Tonight I’m going to write down my three tasks and leave the phone in the kitchen.
Doug: That is a good first experiment. You do not need every answer to take the next step. You only need the next step. Let’s move forward.
Keep Reading
- Overthinking and the Need to Know: Why Your Mind Won’t Stop Asking What If
- Intolerance of Uncertainty as a Treatment Target: What the Evidence Supports (for clinicians; full references)
- Try our free guided breathing exercise, about five minutes
- Breathing Strategies to Lower Anxiety
- Take the GAD-7 anxiety check-in
This conversation is fictional and for education. It is not a substitute for care from a licensed professional. If you or someone you love is in crisis, call or text 988.